I get semi-regular e-mails from Amazon’s “Author Central.” This morning, I received information about their “third annual Amazon Breakthrough Novel Award!”
The exclamation point is theirs, not mine.
The pitch: The Amazon Breakthrough Novel Award offers authors of unpublished or self-published English-language novels a chance to win one of two $15,000 publishing contracts with Penguin USA, and distribution of their novel on Amazon.com. For the first time, Amazon.com customers will vote for two grand prize winners: one for general fiction and one for the best young adult novel. The 2010 competition will now be open to novels that have been previously self-published.
Well, good for you, Amazon.
Though, when I look at the official rules, I am surprised to find this: “We reserve the right, in our sole discretion, to disqualify your Entry from the Contest if the Entry (x) contains obscene, offensive, pornographic or sexually explicit material.”
Really? Let’s look at the language in use.
- obscene
- offensive
- pornographic
- sexually explicit
Most people–not necessarily regular readers of contemporary fiction–would say that obscene and pornographic are synonymous. But maybe Amazon means obscene in the “foul language” sense. That’s fine.
Offensive. Let’s assume they mean “racist” or “hateful.” Also fine. I can accept that.
Pornographic. Material rendered with the intent to titillate. Such passages might be described as…sexually explicit. And I wouldn’t say that such a description is false.
However, aren’t rape scenes sexually explicit? Aren’t there sections of novels which are indeed explicit while also being necessary to the character development of a protagonist?
And how “sexual” does “explicit” material get? Is Slaughterhouse Five explicit? Is The Great Man or The Epicure’s Lament (look these books up…highly recommended) explicit?
Really, on a personal note, what I’m asking is: how do we define “problem” material? And why is it a problem at all?
Though, in this instance, the more important questions are, “How does Amazon define ’sexually explicit?’ How does Penguin?”
I know that my book has sex in it. Six scenes, to be exact. I would describe them as explicit because sex, as most people have experienced it, is explicit and I strive to create fiction which reflects a real time and place. For an eighteen year old girl to encounter five noteworthy sexual experiences–one of the encounters isn’t the hers–over the course of eight years…that seems to derive from a genuine time and place.
Shouldn’t that be worth something better than disregard or disqualification?